20% OFF - American Hardwoods

Happy Father's Day!
Save on select domestic hardwood packs

Shop the Sale
Back to shopping

Reviews for

Currently only viewing 1 star reviews. View All Ratings
Verified Buyer
Patrick I
Mars, PA
I've used it once or twice
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 May 13th, 2025

Very blotchy

Review for 1/4" (5.2mm) Premium Walnut Pre-Cut Plywood Pack (Choose Your Size)

Extremely disappointed in the quality of this plywood, especially for what it cost. Each board has extreme blotching causing a reddish coloration. I am using it for drawer bottoms but still, I expected better quality than this. I bought some white oak veneered 1/4" ply that was way better than this stuff.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Go ahead and surf over to your order history to report a problem. The customer service team will get you fixed.
Verified Buyer
Emily M
Fayetteville, AR
I've used it in several projects
New Woodworker
1 / 5 May 8th, 2025

honestly the worst I have used

Review for 1/4" Premium Walnut Ply on MDF Core Laser Cutter's Bulk Pack 12"x20"

Doesn't cut easily in the laser, the veneer also splinters and the glue holding the veneer is very weak. Definitely won't buy again. I use the Columbia Forest and it's much higher quality.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Bummer! We can get you a store credit. Navigate to your order to report a problem and it will take you through the steps. https://www.woodworkerssource.com/order_history
Verified Buyer
Vidal M
Easton, CT
I haven't used it
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 April 14th, 2025

Order by Size not worth it

Review for Hard White Maple 4/4 Lumber

I ordered several pieces of hard white maple "milled to size" thinking they'd be usable in the custom dimensions. Unfortunately all the pieces had significant tearout and chipping along the rips and aren't even useable unless I trim them down. This defeats the purpose of custom cut, in my opinion--and now I need to purchase new lumber. Would not recommend custom cut purchases, especially when Woodworkers Source "making it right" meant giving me a nominal store credit that wouldn't even replace 1 piece.
Verified Buyer
Connor B
Bluffton, SC
I haven't used it
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 January 2nd, 2025

Over half the wood is cupped or bowed

Review for Walnut Cutting Board Kit

Over half the wood is cupped or bowed.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Dang, sorry about that. We will replace it. Head to your order history and you'll see a button to submit a problem with your order. We'll take care of it.
Verified Buyer
Sean
I haven't used it
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 May 6th, 2024

Full of voids and not stable

Review for 3/4" (18mm) Lightweight Premcore Plus White Birch Plywood Full Size 4'x8'— Store Pickup

First, the edges were full of broken up pieces of wood and you couldn't touch them without getting a splinter.\r\n\r\nSecond, there were so many voids in this plywood its basically not plywood. More like random pieces of plies glued together but not in any fasion that is stable or uniform.\r\n\r\nThird, 2 of the 4 boards were bowed when I received them. What am I suppose to do with bowed plywood?\r\n\r\nHonestly I am disappointed. I thought that buying from a local box store was bad as far as plywood products go. But this plywood was actually worse than box store plywood. I don't know where these other 5 star reviews are coming from, did they receive the same.\r\n\r\nI wish I had the same great experience as others buying from woodworkers source but I just havn't.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Dang, sorry about that. Let's get you a refund or replacement in process! Log into your account, navigate to your order and locate the "Report a Problem" button. We'll get you whatever you need. Thanks!
Verified Buyer
Sean
I haven't used it
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 May 6th, 2024

Full of voids and not stable

Review for 3/4" (18mm) Lightweight Premcore Plus White Birch Plywood Full Size 4'x8'— Store Pickup

First, the edges were full of broken up pieces of wood and you couldn't touch them without getting a splinter. Second, there were so many voids in this plywood its basically not plywood. More like random pieces of plies glued together but not in any fasion that is stable or uniform. Third, 2 of the 4 boards were bowed when I received them. What am I suppose to do with bowed plywood? Honestly I am disappointed. I thought that buying from a local box store was bad as far as plywood products go. But this plywood was actually worse than box store plywood. I don't know where these other 5 star reviews are coming from, did they receive the same. I wish I had the same great experience as others buying from woodworkers source but I just havn't.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Dang, sorry about that. Let's get you a refund or replacement in process! Log into your account, navigate to your order and locate the "Report a Problem" button. We'll get you whatever you need. Thanks!
Verified Buyer
Dennis Boyle
I've used it once or twice
Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 February 21st, 2024

Low quality. Lots of tear out and several dents.

Review for 3/4" (18mm) Hardwood Ply Core White Melamine Pre-Cut Sheets Pack (Choose Your Size)

This product was quite disappointing, especially given the price. Every piece had tear out along the edges and several pieces were dented. Some of the rips were done sloppily so the edges were not flat. I was able to cut it on my miter and table saws using a 80 tooth blade with zero tear out, so I don’t see why that couldn’t have been done by Woodworkers Source.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry to hear it. Let's get you some replacements or a credit. Locate the "Report a Problem" button on your order to get the process started, we'll set you up 👍
Verified Buyer

I haven't used it
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 January 10th, 2024

None of the distinctive leopardwood pattern

Review for Leopardwood (Quarter Sawn) 4/4 Lumber

I think we all buy this wood for the cool pattern, but I didn't get it at all. I was looking forward to getting this piece, but I could barely distinguish it from a Mahogany piece I received at the same time. I'm making small boxes from this type of wood, so the pattern is central to my pieces.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Let's get you a refund or replacement in process! Log into your account, navigate to your order and locate the "Report a Problem" button. We'll get you whatever you need. Thanks!
Verified Buyer
Joe D
Sulphur, OK
I've used it in several projects
Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 January 6th, 2024

Not truly quarter sawn wood

Review for African Mahogany (Quarter Sawn) 8/4 Lumber

Not quarter sawn. I even a notation that the grain needs to be vertical. The grain in both pieces is 45 degrees. It is useless for the purpose I bought it for which was to make splines to repair broken guitar necks and headstocks. I suppose I can find another use for it, but it can't be used to make a guitar necks. To make a spline, I will have to resaw it at 45 degrees, and that is a waste of wood.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Let's get you a refund or replacement in process! Log into your account, navigate to your order and locate the "Report a Problem" button. We'll get you whatever you need. Thanks!
Verified Buyer
Eric Knight
Omaha, NE
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 April 8th, 2023

Took forever to get!!

Review for 1/2" (12mm) Lightweight Premcore Plus White Birch Pre-Cut Plywood Pack (Choose Your Size)

How hard is it to get this right???
Verified Buyer
KFK
Wisconsin
I've used it once or twice
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 February 4th, 2023

Everything on order was great, birch ply not so much

Review for 1/2" (12mm) Lightweight Premcore Plus White Birch Plywood Full Size 4'x8'— Store Pickup

Not what I was expecting. Dinged edges and thick layers. Unbelieveable. BOOOO! Won't be back, screw you.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry to hear about this! Customer Service will be in touch to get you a replacement piece.
Verified Buyer
n/a
1085 Banner loop Concord AR
I haven't used it yet
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 April 15th, 2021

Low quality

Review for Bocote 4/4 Lumber

Splits in all of my material, one board is split all the way through, another had a split at the end, another had parts unplained causing non uniform thickness. And can send photos if needed for further compensation
Woodworkers Source Responds
Oh no! Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
Bob
n/a
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 November 1st, 2019

Mesquite 8/4 lumber

Review for Mesquite 8/4 Lumber

Very disappointed in this lumber. Contained major cracks and checks which renders the lumber useless for intended purpose (cutting boards).
Woodworkers Source Responds
We're sorry if it wasn't clear that mesquite does contain a lot of that. Customer service will contact you today about replacing it with a different choice.
Verified Buyer
Schroed
Utah
I haven't used it yet
Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 July 2nd, 2019

OMG, ooops

Review for 1/2" Baltic Birch Pre-Cut Plywood Pack (Choose Your Size)

all 3 pieces were terribly bowed...was sold on the flatness of baltic birch to make sleds and jigs, but this sh*t is no way usable for that. Maybe some drawer bottoms or sacrificial uses...
Woodworkers Source Responds
I apologize for the trouble. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
Greg
Tennessee
I've used it in several projects
Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 April 19th, 2019

Both pieces split down the middle

Review for Natural Hickory 8/4 Lumber

Ordered 2 - 8/4 pieces of hickory. Both split down the middle. One piece the split has rendered half the board unusable for the project. The entire idea of order 8/4 is that you need thicker wood. By the time i plane down, it will be a 4/4. Each piece was $50 each. I would cost me that much to ship them back. Not worth the hassle.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
n/a
n/a
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 December 20th, 2018

boring

Review for 1-3/4" Black Limba Pre-Cut Squares

The wood is very light and my pieces were very plain with no interesting characteristics. I turned them round and took them off the lathe. Just plain light colored light weight wood.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
Ernie
Ludlow Ma
I've used it once or twice
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 October 20th, 2018

Cherry wood

Review for Cherry 4/4 Lumber

The wood was all cracked and not very useable, I'm very disappointed. Will not order again!!!
Woodworkers Source Responds
Oh no! Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you to issue replacements.
Seth
Hollywood
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 September 4th, 2018

Jointer Not What It Seems

Review for JET 8'' Benchtop Planer Jointer

I bought this to roll all my joints and instead this thing about shredded my hands when I placed the baggie and rolling papers in it. I would definitely not recommend this product!!! Do it the old fashioned way.
Verified Buyer
BlindMan60
Mass
I've used it once or twice
Semi-Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 August 8th, 2018

Very poor quality

Review for Quilted Maple 4/4 Lumber

So I ordered this quilted maple just 6bf so I could have an idea how the quality would be. I also ordered other wood, The other wood was Fine just as described. The quilted maple was four boards 2 of them were warped badly, one only had figure on a quarter of the board, I emailed the help desk & They were very sorry that this happened & They are going too replace the wood
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Anthony
CA
I've used it in several projects
Semi-Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 July 30th, 2018

First Batch Good, Second Not So Much

Review for 1/8" Baltic Birch Pre-Cut Plywood Pack (Choose Your Size)

So far I've ordered two batches for use in a laser cutter. The first batch worked great, easy to cut, and looked good. The second batch had a lot of more patches and even knot voids in the surface. Often one side would be patched while the other had knots with uneven surface coloration. It also cut very inconsistently with the laser often having areas that would not go through. When I used an exacto knife to finish cuts the laser would start it often appeared that there were clumps of glue that the laser would cut through. Over all I've had to both increase the power I'm cutting at and vastly decrease the my cutting speed. I've tested with other pieces of material and everything works fine, so my only conclusion is a bad batch of ply. I will NOT be ordering again.
Verified Buyer
SKM
NC
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 June 18th, 2018

Warped

Review for Hard White Maple 4/4 Lumber

All three maple boards shipped were warped. Limited what I could do with them. Disappointed.
Woodworkers Source Responds
I apologize for the trouble. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
Ammateur WW
California
I haven't used it yet
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 May 8th, 2018

Customer disappointed

Review for Classic Cutting Board Kit - Maple, Cherry & Walnut

I ordered the cutting board kit -Walnut, Mahogany & Maple on April 7 and it arrived about a week later incomplete (glue and oil were missing!) and with a piece of wood damaged with a large dent The USPS box did not have any damage and was sealed. I called Woodworkers Source and their personnel requested to send pictures of the damaged board, which I did same day. They assured that the missing components of the kit and the damaged board will be sent in due course. However, after a month of placing the original order, I have not received anything. Very disappointed with their customer service and the lack of seriousness with their commitment.
Verified Buyer
n/a
n/a
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 January 27th, 2018

Not sastified

Review for Purple Heart Hardwood Sample (1/2"x3"x6")

I ordered 3x9 and got something way smaller
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
T
Md
I haven't used it yet
Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 December 28th, 2017

Not good

Review for Walnut Black Hardwood Sample (1/2"x3"x6")

That scrap piece should be free
Verified Buyer
Erik
Long Island NY
I haven't used it yet
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 October 5th, 2017

4/4 Hickory - lots of sapwood

Review for Natural Hickory 4/4 Lumber

Was pretty excited to see the price on the hickory - but when i got it was a little disappointed. I got 4 total boards and all of them are literally half and half sapwood/heartwood. I didn't specify that i wanted only heartwood, but honestly didn't think i would have to. It's sawn well enough and the boards are fairly clear, just have to figure out what I'll do with boards that are 50/50 heart/sap. Definitely be sure to put in a note if you want only heartwood or else you are rolling the dice with less "desirable" boards.
Ray
Buffalo Ny
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 September 6th, 2017

Scrap wood

Review for Alder 8/4 Lumber

Ordered 12 bf and when I opened it up it had 5 knots throughout the 2 pieces I was sent. I ordered so I could build a few guitar bodies and will be lucky to get 1&1/2 out of what I was sent. Emailed and called and had to leave a message and no response from customer service.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
T&T
Conroe Texas
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 February 8th, 2017

Leopard wood

Review for 1-3/4" Leopardwood Pre-Cut Squares

When I ordered the Leopard wood turning spuares i was hoping for larger spots like the pictures that were on line, the spots are very small not very visible.
Woodworkers Source Responds
We can replace it. Customer service will contact you.
Keith
CO
I've used it in several projects
Semi-Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 January 24th, 2017

HUGE PRICE INCREASE FOR 2017!

Review for 1/8" Baltic Birch Pre-Cut Plywood Pack (Choose Your Size)

I've boughten over 100x of these packs since 2015. There has been a 30%...30% increase on the item and also a 20% on shipping! This is insane guys! Now I'm forced to find a better price some where else. Good product, usually not too warped, but not price isn't justified.
Verified Buyer
Richard cedar
Derrick city
I've used it once or twice
New Woodworker
1 / 5 January 17th, 2017

Lots of knots

Review for Premium Black Walnut 4/4 Lumber, Clear One Side

Alot of the walnut in my past order was full of holes and not usable.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Verified Buyer
Michael
California
I've used it once or twice
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 December 8th, 2016

1st Bad Experience

Review for Hard White Maple 8/4 Lumber

As sometimes happens, this 4" x 90" piece of 8/4 maple twisted and bent badly once I'd ripped it into 1" strips to use for the facing of a new built-in bookshelf. I've never had a problem this bad with your products before.
Woodworkers Source Responds
I apologize for the trouble. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Dan
Levittown pa
I haven't used it yet
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 February 11th, 2016

Lifeless

Review for Goncalo Alves 4/4 Lumber

Came as one completely tan board, with maybe 2 or 3 spots that were a SHADE darker. Plain red oak is prettier. Ordered this board over a year ago and is still sitting on my rack unused. Thought I just misjudged the pics on the website but when my local lumberyard got some in stock I knew I wasted my money here. They had deep black streaking throughout all their boards (which apparently this website only sells as "special") To date I've ordered through woodworkerssource 4 or 5 times and this was the only bad experience, but man, what an expensive and lifeless board they sent me.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Michael S.
Mundelein IL United States
I've used it once or twice
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 January 14th, 2015

No purple

Review for Purple Heart Hardwood Sample (1/2"x3"x6")

I was excited to finally see some purple heart in person and to use it to make a bow handle, however when it arrived the block of wood was completely brown. Not even a tinge of color after I sanded it and finished it with tung oil. It was a disappointment.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Ah! Sorry about that, Michael. The purple color in purple heart comes from oxidization. Fresh cut and worked purple heart will be brown. Give it some sunshine, in a day you'll notice a difference as the purple color comes back.
Steve
n/a
I haven't used it yet
New Woodworker
1 / 5 November 17th, 2011

4/4 piece split down the middle

Review for Cherry 4/4 Lumber

One piece you sent had a crack right across the center, chuck missing. I needed a full 51 inches so it was useless to me
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sounds like we need to replace this. Customer service will be in touch to get it straightened out
LK
Circleville OH USA
I haven't used it yet
Enthusiast Woodworker
1 / 5 August 19th, 2011

Not to size

Review for 1-3/4" Hard White Maple Pre-Cut Squares

Material was a little less than 1-7/8" square instead of 2" square. We could not make our finished parts from them because they were too small.
Carl Pitts
Tucson AZ US
1 / 5 March 16th, 2011

botched order

Review for Hard White Maple 8/4 Lumber

I ordered, and was charged for 6', of this lumber no less than 5" or more than 6" wide. What I received was 4' 7.5" long by 6.5" wide. I paid a premium of 50 cents per foot ($3.00) to be able to choose the length and width of the lumber I wanted. Neither end of the board I received was cut square. I leave you to draw your own conclusions whether this is a rip off or not.
Mark Patrick
Sheridan Wyo. US
I haven't used it yet
Hobbyist Woodworker
1 / 5 December 2nd, 2010

Purple Heart

Review for Purple Heart Hardwood Sample (1/2"x3"x6")

The pic on your web page made it look a lot more purple. The piece I received was not purple at all. I use the wood for making knife handles, they work perfectly. My daughter wants a purple handle on hers, not sure what or where I will find any purple LOL. I really love the Leapord wood and will be ording several more in about 2 weeks. All the other wood I have ordered from you is just wonderful, perfect. Thank you very much.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry about that. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Kenneth Ray Freeman
Kyle Texas usa
I haven't used it yet
Semi-Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 November 24th, 2010

Small shop wood

Review for Hard White Maple 8/4 Lumber

Now this lumber I was very disappointed.It was VERY ROUGH on both faces and had several splits.In my view no worth the money I paid.I dont have the time to repackage lumber and ship it back so I will just have to plane it down smooth and use what I have.
Woodworkers Source Responds
Sorry to hear about this. You don't have to ship it back to get some resolution though. Customer service will contact you today about a replacement.
Dexter Bartlett
Pittsford MI USA
1 / 5 July 13th, 2010

Not exactly what I ordered!

Review for Basswood 12/4 Lumber

Received a large piece of basswood that when cut up would be that which I ordered. In other words, instead of the six pieces of wood that was ordered, I received one large piece.
IJK
n/a
I've used it once or twice
Semi-Professional Woodworker
1 / 5 May 12th, 2009

Lucky to get 1 5/8

Review for 1-3/4" Red Oak Pre-Cut Squares

I am not happy with this product. A variance in stock lumber would be acceptable but I expected a more consistent dimension for turning blanks. Unfortunately, the rough sawn sides are on the short dimension so after planing I expect I will get something close to 1-5/8" X 2".
Woodworkers Source Responds
Uh oh, agreed, that's no good. Customer service will be in touch to get you some replacements.